Gemini, Google's generative AI tool, says we can't.

Last June, LMP professor emerita and former Medical School dean Deborah Powell and four colleagues published a New England Journal of Medicine “Perspective” entitled “Pathobiology – Can We Do Without It?” 

In stressing the importance of pathobiology in the medical school curriculum, the authors conclude:  “In an era in which medical practice is becoming more complex and the role of nonphysician health care professionals (such as physician assistants, advanced practice nurses, and pharmacists) is expanding, the physician’s role as an expert diagnostician is especially vital to the work of the health care team. We believe the medical community can’t afford to train the physicians of the future — particularly general internists, general surgeons, and family physicians — in programs that fail to develop this essential competency in students.”

Deborah Powell photoPowell said she received many email messages after the article was published.  Most were from pathologists but clinicians weighed in, too, mainly from internal medicine and neurology.  She invited one respondent who is in leadership at the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs to give an LMP Grand Rounds to acquaint residents with VA career opportunities for pathologists.  “Overall, I was really pleased that the article resonated with so many people,” she said.  “We should all be concerned about the ‘de-emphasis’ on science in medicine.”

In July, the University’s Office of Information Technology announced that “Gemini, Google’s cutting-edge generative AI tool with Enterprise-Grade Security--is available to students, faculty, and staff.” 

On August 6, 12 pm., I queried Gemini with the following:  “Pathobiology – Can We Do Without It?”  What follows are the results.  Emphasis in the original.  Note that subsequent queries using the same prompt yielded slightly different results.

 

 

Pathobiology – Can We Do Without It?

No, we can’t do without pathobiology. Pathobiology is a critical, foundational science that bridges the gap between basic biological research and clinical medicine.  It’s the scientific study of disease mechanisms, focusing on how diseases develop and affect the body at the molecular, cellular, and tissue levels. Without pathobiology, our understanding of illness would be superficial, and our ability to develop effective diagnostics, treatments, and preventive strategies would be severely limited.

What is Pathobiology?

Pathobiology is an interdisciplinary field that uses tools from molecular biology, cell biology, biochemistry, and immunology to understand the fundamental processes of disease.  While it’s closely related to pathology – the medical specialty that diagnoses diseases – pathobiology focuses more on the “why” and “how” of disease.  For example, a pathologist might diagnose a tumor by examining tissue under a microscope, but a pathobiologist would investigate the genetic mutations and cellular signaling pathways that caused the tumor to grow in the first place.

The field is essential for:

  • Understanding disease origins:  It helps us uncover the initial triggers and subsequent cascades of events that lead to conditions like cancer, Alzheimer’s, or infectious diseases.

  • Developing new therapies:  By pinpointing the specific genetic abnormalities in a disease, pathobiology provides the targets for drug development. For example, understanding a particular protein’s role in disease allows scientists to design drugs that block or activate that protein.

  • Improving diagnostics:  The knowledge gained from pathobiology leads to the creation of more accurate and specific diagnostic tests, such as those that detect a specific gene mutation or protein level in a patient’s blood.

  • Advancing personalized medicine: Pathobiology is at the core of personalized medicine, which tailors treatments to an individual’s unique genetic makeup and disease characteristics.  This approach relies on a deep understanding of the individual’s specific pathobiology

Pathobiology’s Role in Medical Progress

Pathobiology’s contributions are woven into the fabric of modern medicine.  It’s a cornerstone of medical education and research, providing the essential knowledge that informs every clinical discipline.  From developing new cancer immunotherapies to creating vaccines against infectious pathogens, the progress we’ve made in medicine is directly tied to a deeper understanding of pathobiology.  Without this discipline, medical science would be unable to advance beyond mere observation and symptomatic treatment, leaving us without the tools to truly combat the root causes of diseases.